Sun, Mar 2, 2025

India reduces poverty, debunks popular myth

India
Sarah   J

Sarah J

Posted on Sun, Mar 2, 2025

5 min read

Share the article with your network

x
Facebook
linkedin

India's recent strides in reducing extreme poverty to negligible levels, as highlighted in a 2025 article from The Economist titled "India has undermined a popular myth about development", mark a significant shift in global development narratives. This survey note delves into the data, policies, and implications, providing a comprehensive analysis for researchers, policymakers, and lay readers interested in development economics.


Background and Context

The article, published on February 27, 2025, and featured in the Finance & economics section of the March 1, 2025, print edition under the headline “Ploughing its own furrow,” suggests that India has challenged a popular myth about development. While the specific myth isn't detailed in accessible snippets, the context points to the notion that extreme poverty is persistent and difficult to eradicate in large, developing nations. This is supported by the article's mention that "extreme poverty in the country has dropped to negligible levels," aligning with broader discussions on India's poverty reduction trajectory.


Defining Extreme Poverty

Extreme poverty, as defined by the World Bank, is living on less than $2.15 per day in 2022 purchasing power parity (PPP) terms, reflecting severe deprivation in basic needs. This metric is crucial for international comparisons and tracking progress toward global development goals, such as the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals.


Data on Poverty Reduction

Historical data from the World Bank indicates that India's extreme poverty rate was 22.5% in 2011, affecting approximately 295 million people, and decreased to 10.2% by 2019, impacting about 140 million. More recent estimates, such as those from a 2024 Brookings Institution article titled "India eliminates extreme poverty", suggest that by 2025, official data confirms the elimination of extreme poverty, with the rate now negligible. This is further supported by the National Multidimensional Poverty Index: A Progress Review 2023 from the United Nations Development Programme, which reports that 135 million people escaped multidimensional poverty between 2015-16 and 2019-21, with rural areas seeing the fastest decline from 32.59% to 19.28% National Multidimensional Poverty Index: A Progress Review 2023.


| Year  | Extreme Poverty Rate (%) | Estimated Population in Extreme Poverty (Millions) |

|--------|--------------------------|------------------

| 2011  | 22.5           | ~295                       |

| 2019  | 10.2           | ~140                       |

| 2025  | Negligible        | <1% (assumed based on recent reports)       |


This table summarizes the trend, highlighting the significant reduction and the projected negligible levels by 2025, based on the Brookings claim.


Factors Contributing to Poverty Reduction

Several interrelated factors have driven India's success, as evidenced by various reports and government initiatives:


1. Economic Growth and Structural Changes:

  - India's GDP growth averaged 6-7% annually, driven by sectors like services (now nearly 50% of GDP, as per The India Forum in 2024) and technology, creating jobs and raising incomes. This growth, particularly post-1991 liberalization, has been crucial, though manufacturing's share remained stagnant, per Poverty in India Over the Last Decade.


2. Government Policies and Programs:

  - Infrastructure Investment: Enhanced roads, railways, and ports have improved connectivity, facilitating economic activity. The Economic Survey 2022-23 highlights significant investments in infrastructure Economic Survey 2022-23

  - Social Safety Nets: The National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) guarantees 100 days of wage employment to rural households, with over 5 billion person-days of employment generated since inception, according to government reports.

  - Direct Benefit Transfers: Programs like the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) have opened over 400 million bank accounts, reducing financial exclusion, as noted in the 2023 Economic Survey.


3. Access to Basic Services:

  - Electricity: The Saubhagya scheme aimed for universal electrification, with significant progress reported, improving productivity and living standards.

  - Water and Sanitation: The Swachh Bharat Mission, launched in 2014, constructed over 100 million toilets, reducing open defecation and improving health outcomes, as per the 2023 Multidimensional Poverty Index report.

  - Healthcare: The National Rural Health Mission expanded healthcare access, particularly in rural areas, contributing to reduced infant mortality and improved health indicators.


4. Digitalization and Financial Inclusion:

 - Digital payment systems like the Unified Payments Interface (UPI) have revolutionized transactions, with over 40 billion transactions in 2023, enhancing economic participation. PMJDY's success in opening accounts has been pivotal, with data from the Reserve Bank of India showing increased banking penetration.


Challenging the Popular Myth

The popular myth that India has undermined appears to be the belief that extreme poverty is intractable in large, developing countries, often attributed to population size, diversity, and structural challenges. India's success, with a population of over 1.4 billion, challenges this assumption, suggesting that with targeted policies, even the most daunting development goals can be met.


Additionally, it undermines the notion that development requires a specific governance model, such as autocracy, which some argue is necessary for rapid decision-making. India's democratic system, combined with a mixed economy, has shown that inclusive growth is possible, contradicting myths highlighted in discussions like *The Myth of Democratic Recession* from the Journal of Democracy in 2015 The Myth of Democratic Recession. This is an unexpected insight, as many global observers assumed only authoritarian regimes could achieve such rapid poverty reduction, as discussed in Democracy does not cause growth from the Brookings Institution in 2016.


Controversies and Challenges

While the narrative is positive, controversies exist around poverty measurement methods. Some, like Poverty in India Over the Last Decade from The India Forum, caution that until unit-level data is analyzed, claims of eliminating extreme poverty may be premature, especially given data-related controversies around the National Statistical Organisation's surveys. Additionally, critics argue that the $2.15 poverty line might be too low, with Five myths about India's poverty from McKinsey in 2014 suggesting that 56% of Indians lack means for basic needs, challenging official rates Five myths about India's poverty.


Implications for Global Development

India's achievement serves as a model for other developing nations, particularly in demonstrating that democracy and mixed economies can drive poverty reduction. It also highlights the importance of inclusive policies, such as digitalization and financial inclusion, which can be adapted globally. As noted in India Overview: Development news, research, data from the World Bank in 2024, India's aspiration to achieve high-income status by 2047 will need to build on these gains, focusing on climate-resilient and inclusive growth India Overview: Development news, research, data


India's conquest of extreme poverty by 2025, reducing it to negligible levels, is a significant development breakthrough, challenging the myth of its persistence in large, developing countries. Driven by economic growth, government initiatives, and improved access to services, this success underscores the potential for diverse development paths. As global development discourse evolves, India's experience offers valuable lessons, emphasizing the need for tailored, inclusive strategies to build a more equitable world.


---

Join the exclusive network for leaders driving growth and partnerships in tech and science - www.startupeuropeindia.net


You may also like

Sarah   J

Sarah J

Fri, May 2, 2025

Trump’s Tariffs Threaten India’s Diamond Industry and Global Trade Flows

India’s diamond industry, the world’s largest by volume, is facing one of its toughest challenges yet after the United States imposed new tariffs on polished diamond imports. This move, part of a broader escalation in global trade tensions, is sending shockwaves through the city of Surat, where most of the world’s diamonds are cut and polished.The U.S. is the single largest market for Indian diamonds, accounting for nearly half of all exports. With the new tariffs in place, Indian stones are suddenly more expensive for American buyers, prompting jewelry retailers to reconsider their supply chains and causing anxiety among exporters in India.For workers in Surat, the impact is immediate. Many small workshops, already grappling with thin margins and fluctuating demand, are seeing orders cancelled or postponed. Factory owners are cutting shifts, and thousands of workers face the prospect of layoffs. For families who depend on this industry, the uncertainty is palpable.Industry leaders warn that the ripple effects could extend beyond India. Higher prices for American consumers may dampen demand for diamond jewelry, especially in a market already sensitive to economic headwinds. U.S. retailers, caught between rising costs and cautious shoppers, may look to alternative sources or push for lower prices, squeezing margins throughout the supply chain.The tariffs also threaten to disrupt the delicate balance of global trade. India’s diamond sector is a major employer and a significant source of foreign exchange. Prolonged disruption could prompt Indian exporters to accelerate efforts to diversify away from the U.S. market, seeking new buyers in Europe, the Middle East, and beyond. However, building new relationships and adapting to different consumer preferences will take time.For now, the industry is in wait-and-see mode. Exporters are lobbying for government support and exploring ways to add value, such as offering certified stones or unique cuts, to justify higher prices. Some are investing in technology to improve efficiency and reduce costs, hoping to weather the storm.The broader lesson is clear: in an era of rising protectionism, even industries with deep global roots are vulnerable. The fate of India’s diamond workers is a stark reminder that trade policy decisions made in Washington can have profound consequences in distant corners of the world. As the industry adapts, resilience and innovation will be crucial for survival.---Join SEINET – the Europe-India Tech &amp; Science Corridor.Connect seamlessly with industry leaders, startups, and organizations driving innovation across borders. Sales, Partners and M&amp;A on www.startupeuropeindia.net
Fri, May 2, 2025
Trump’s Tariffs Threaten India’s Diamond Industry and Global Trade Flows
Sarah   J

Sarah J

Fri, May 2, 2025

UK-India Investment Treaty to Include Landmark Clause Allowing Companies to Sue Governments

A new investment treaty between the United Kingdom and India is set to make headlines with a provision that will allow companies from either country to sue the other’s government if they believe policy changes have unfairly harmed their investments or profits. This move, confirmed by two sources familiar with the negotiations, marks a significant shift in the approach both nations have taken toward investor protections in recent years.Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) Back in FocusAt the heart of the treaty is the Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) mechanism. ISDS allows corporations to take legal action against governments if they feel domestic policy changes have negatively impacted their business interests. The mechanism is designed to protect companies from what they see as unfair treatment under local laws. The treaty, expected to be finalized alongside a broader free trade agreement, signals a willingness by both countries to provide greater legal certainty for foreign investors.This is a notable development given that, since leaving the European Union, the UK has avoided including ISDS in any of its bilateral free trade agreements, although it remains a feature of the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), which the UK has joined. India, for its part, has also moved to restrict the use of ISDS in its treaties, especially after terminating a previous bilateral investment treaty with the UK in 2017. India’s newer model only allows ISDS claims after all domestic legal options have been exhausted.Why Now? Business Confidence and Political ShiftsAccording to one source, the UK pushed for the inclusion of ISDS in the new deal, reflecting British businesses’ desire for stronger assurances that they will be treated fairly under the Indian legal system. The Indian government has not commented publicly on the ongoing talks. A spokesperson for Britain’s trade ministry declined to discuss the specifics but stressed that any agreement must guarantee fair treatment for businesses.The Labour Party, which returned to power in the UK last year, has been eager to present itself as pro-business and to restart trade talks that had stalled under previous administrations. “We are committed to enhancing access for UK businesses, guaranteeing their fair treatment, reducing tariffs, and simplifying trade,” a UK trade ministry spokesperson said.Track Record and ControversyBritain has never lost an ISDS case, but UN data shows that of the 30 ISDS claims brought against India since 2003, eight were initiated by UK-based companies under a previous agreement. The ISDS mechanism has not been without controversy. Critics, including the UK’s former Conservative government, have warned that ISDS can hinder efforts to address climate change, as fossil fuel companies have used it to protect their assets from new environmental policies.What’s Next? Final Talks and Remaining HurdlesNegotiations between the UK and India have been ongoing, on and off, since January 2022. The Indian Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal was in London earlier this week for advanced discussions and returned on Friday for further talks. Key sticking points remain, including tariffs on whisky, automobiles, and agricultural products, as well as regulatory issues in the pharmaceutical sector.India’s previous opposition to ISDS led to the scrapping of the earlier bilateral investment treaty with the UK in 2017. The new agreement appears to be a compromise, balancing investor protections with domestic legal safeguards.For businesses and investors, the inclusion of ISDS is a clear signal that both governments are seeking to create a more predictable and secure environment for cross-border investment. As one UK official put it, the aim is to “improve access for UK businesses, ensure their fair treatment, cut tariffs, and make trade cheaper and easier”.---Join SEINET – the Europe-India Tech &amp; Science Corridor.Connect seamlessly with industry leaders, startups, and organizations driving innovation across borders. Sales, Partners and M&amp;A on www.startupeuropeindia.net
Fri, May 2, 2025
UK-India Investment Treaty to Include Landmark Clause Allowing Companies to Sue Governments
Sarah   J

Sarah J

Sun, Apr 27, 2025

India’s Tech Talent Embraces the AI Revolution

India’s technology sector, long a global powerhouse for IT services and software development, is undergoing a seismic shift as artificial intelligence (AI) reshapes the industry. With a workforce of over 5 million tech professionals and a burgeoning startup ecosystem, the country is rapidly adapting to the AI era, balancing challenges with immense opportunities.A Workforce in TransitionThe rise of AI is transforming job roles across India’s tech landscape. Traditional tasks like coding and data analysis are increasingly augmented by AI tools, pushing professionals to upskill in areas like machine learning, natural language processing, and AI ethics. Companies such as Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) and Infosys are investing heavily in reskilling programs, training thousands of employees to work alongside AI systems. For instance, TCS’s AI-focused training initiatives aim to prepare its workforce for “human-AI collaboration,” ensuring employees remain relevant in an automated world.This shift isn’t limited to large corporations. India’s startup ecosystem, with over 1,200 AI-driven startups, is fostering a culture of innovation. Entrepreneurs and developers are leveraging AI to solve local challenges, from improving agricultural yields to enhancing healthcare diagnostics. This entrepreneurial spirit is supported by government initiatives like the National AI Strategy, which promotes AI adoption and skill development.Education and Skill DevelopmentIndia’s education system is also adapting to meet AI-driven demands. Universities and online platforms are introducing specialized AI and data science courses, with institutions like the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) and Indian Institute of Science (IISc) leading the charge. Meanwhile, edtech platforms like UpGrad and Coursera report a surge in enrollments for AI-related certifications, reflecting a growing appetite among young professionals to master these skills.However, challenges remain. The pace of AI adoption outstrips the supply of highly skilled talent, creating a gap between industry needs and available expertise. Rural areas, in particular, face barriers to accessing quality education and internet connectivity, limiting participation in the AI economy. Addressing these disparities is critical to ensuring inclusive growth.Economic and Global ImpactIndia’s AI adaptation is poised to bolster its $250 billion IT industry. By integrating AI, companies are improving efficiency, reducing costs, and delivering innovative solutions to global clients. For example, Indian firms are developing AI-powered tools for industries like finance, retail, and manufacturing, positioning the country as a leader in AI outsourcing.Globally, India’s tech talent is gaining recognition for its ability to deliver scalable AI solutions. Multinational corporations, including Google and Microsoft, are expanding their AI research hubs in India, drawn by the country’s vast talent pool and cost advantages. This trend underscores India’s growing influence in shaping the global AI landscape.Despite the optimism, the AI era brings challenges. Job displacement fears loom large, particularly for roles involving repetitive tasks. Industry leaders emphasize the need for proactive reskilling to mitigate these risks. Additionally, ethical concerns around AI, such as data privacy and algorithmic bias, are prompting discussions on responsible AI development. Indian policymakers and companies are beginning to prioritize frameworks for ethical AI, aligning with global standards.India’s tech talent is at a pivotal moment, embracing AI as both a challenge and an opportunity. With robust investments in education, government support, and a dynamic startup ecosystem, the country is well-positioned to thrive in the AI era. As one industry expert noted, “India’s ability to adapt and innovate will determine its place in the global AI race.” By fostering collaboration between industry, academia, and government, India is not just keeping pace with the AI revolution—it’s helping shape its future.---Join the Premier Europe-India Network for Technology and Science Leaders and Organizations Across Europe, the UK, and IndiaRegister free&nbsp;www.startupeuropeindia.net
Sun, Apr 27, 2025
India’s Tech Talent Embraces the AI Revolution